A lot alike to our other plays...

M. Butterfly can be compared with every single other play we've read over the semester. The idea of deceit is abundant in one form or another.

Let's start with "Art." When Yvan, Serge and Marc begin fighting near the end of the play, they let each other know how they really feel. In essence, they've been lying and decieving and pretending all those years.

"Amadeus" is easy. Salieri befriends Mozart until the moment when he can hurt him most presents itself. Last time I checked up on that sort of thing, it was an obvious form of deceit.

Yet another obvious one is "Spinning Into Butter." Simon as the victim to his own crimes is pretty deceitful. That's not to say that Sarah's hidden racism isn't deceitful, but Simon is the obvious one.

The only thing I can think of for "Joe Turner" is Jesse. His habit of wooing women then cheating on them is all that I could come up with. Bynum's pigeon sacrifices are secretive, but not a secret.

In "Doubt" Sister Aloisyous acts deceitful towards Father Flynn. She invites him in, telling him to expect a discussion about the pageant. It never makes you feel that the deceit is mean though. Deceit is deceit I guess.

Deceit in "All My Sons" is everywhere. However, the main form of deceit is Joe keeping his secret from nearly everyone in his life. That is probably one of the biggest examples of deceit from the class. He hid the war accident from everyone for years. That's the kind of deceit that needs talent.

The inly play that I couldn't find a concrete example of deceit in was "Mother Courage and Her Children." If I had to pick something fromm the play, it would maybe be Mother Courage's haggling abd hoodwinking habits.

And the example in "M. Butterfly" is Song's deceit towards Rene. I still would like to know how you don't notice obvious extremeties after being with someone for 20 years. Generally speaking, the main idea of an affair is to sleep with someone besides your significant other for as long as you can get away with it.

What are some other recurring themes that others noticed?

Song of Fraternization

After leafing through the play a second time, I found the "Song of Fraternization" to be the most intriguing. I think Yvette's song is probably the most involved, and could probably be put as a seperate story all by itself. It's a good story and it fits nicely in with Kattrin's character. I also think Prof. Newby put it nicely by calling her a "Woman of Convenience."

First of all, Yvette's story can be easily compared to Kattrin's, making the morals and warnings all the more possible. Yvette claims she followed the army around, offering a certain service to those that needed it. How is Kattrin much different? She is forced to also follow the army around the world, also offering services, albeit not the same kind of service.

Mother Courage is not helping the situation either. She starts the play off by tossing her daughters purity and innocence out the window by claiming she's being courted by the Lieutenant. So, even before we get to hear the "Song of Fraternization," Mother Courage is not setting a great example, despite the fact she is incredible at her job as a mother.

But, right after Yvette leaves from singing her touching and heart-warming tale, what does Kattrin do? She takes the prostitute's "garbs" and prances around all over the place in a camp full of deprived men. Mother Courage at least does the decent thing and takes her out of the situation.

What other comparisons or differences did you guys think of for this song?

Some contrasts I noticed in Buried Child...

There's a couple of random contrasts I just thought of.

I think the priest's presence physically and outside of the house adds some things to the plot. It's a little ironic that even though Halie has a horrible, unholy secret to keep, she continues to "relate" to the priest. It's almost as if she's going out of her way to convince the priest she's an honest, good person.

Vince and Shelly also seem to start out drastically opposite of Dodge and Halie, both in age and personality. But, near the end, the four of them begin to show more similar characteristics. It's like their personalities are coming together; Halie and Dodge seem to calm, while Vince and Shelly begin to see madness.

Like we talked about in class, the color of their clothing contrast as well. Dodge, Tilden and Halie are all wearing dark, negative, forlorn colors. Then, enter Vince and Shelly wearing sunglasses and a purple t-shirt, respectively.

Anyone else disagree?

Frank is unappreciated...

I think Frank is an unappreciated character. He's just as important as George, but he's given 1/3 of the lines. Think about it; if Frank was scrapped as a character, there would be a lot missing.

For one, the whole horoscope thing would be gone. That eliminates an important scene and concept. There would be no irony to the whole favorable day thing and he wouldn't be able to interrupt the confrontation with George. There would also be even less hope for a good ending for the reader/audience. But that point is obvious.

The more subtle missing piece is with Lydia. If Frank isn't there, there's little point to her as a character. Because of Frank, she's able to claim him as her husband when seeing George. If Frank were absent from the story, she could claim she's single which could very easily be enough to convince George to forgive and stick around.

Frank may not be the lead, but he's definitely a necessary supporting role for the story. Personally, I think Jim and Susan (neighbors) are a little on the useless side. If you guys can think of even more reasons why Frank is important, please leave a comment.